
A common financial myth: Being bullish means you should go all in
In conversations about cryptocurrency, the most common refrain is: “I’m bullish, so I’m going all in.” It sounds decisive and conviction-driven, and it matches the way many people imagine investing: if you see the opportunity clearly, commit everything; hesitation only means missing out. Yet the statement mixes together two entirely different things—a judgment about an asset’s long-term prospects and your personal capacity to bear risk. The first can be discussed in terms of returns; the second is a matter of survival.
More importantly, this myth often uses “holding for the long term” as cover. Crypto’s history of volatility is not theoretical: in December 2017, Bitcoin traded through a nearly 20% single-day decline, while the loss in total market capitalization was far greater; during the market crash in March 2020, most major coins fell between 40% and 70%. Anyone who could remain in the market through those moments paid far more than a paper loss. The costs also included disrupted cash flow, disruption to work, and the possibility of being forced to sell at the bottom.
Therefore, being bullish has never been a sufficient reason to go all in. Making the right judgment and being able to live with the outcome are two different things. When the two are treated as interchangeable, even a temporary adverse move in price gets misread as “I had the fundamentals wrong,” triggering a chain reaction of panic-driven decisions.
The underlying logic flaw: Risk concentration mistaken for risk elimination
The first flaw is mistaking diversification for a drag. People who hold stocks, bonds, funds, and deposits are often considered conservative, while those who concentrate their assets in a single asset are viewed as courageous. In reality, both are simply approaches to asset allocation. The difference lies not in temperament, but in which approach lets you stay in the game under the worst possible conditions. Nobel Prize-winning economist William Sharpe, when discussing the concept of a portfolio, pointed out that the central function of diversification is to keep a single event from determining the entire outcome when the future cannot be predicted.
The second flaw is conflating a price decline with the risk of going to zero. Crypto prices can indeed fall because of market liquidity, regulatory policy, protocol flaws, or technical failures. Some of these factors can even drive the value of a particular token close to zero. That is not a worst-case scenario; it has already happened. The Mt. Gox exchange incident in April 2013 resulted in the theft of approximately 850,000 Bitcoin, worth about $450 million at the time. The collapse of Terra’s algorithmic stablecoin in June 2022 also left UST holders with losses of nearly their entire investments during a wave of panic selling.
The third flaw is misaligning the time horizon. “Long term” sounds reassuring, but it means very different things to different people. Someone with a mortgage payment due in six months and someone with no major expenses coming up for five years cannot possibly react to the same 70% decline in the same way. Risk is not a label attached to an asset itself. It is the result of asset volatility intersecting with the timelines of your liabilities, income, and expenses.
What I actually think: Ask four questions before discussing position size
To assess whether you are suited to a highly concentrated investment in a single high-volatility asset, begin by using four questions to examine your risk structure. The first concerns the nature of the funds: could this money be drawn on within the next three years? If the answer is “very likely,” its role has already been defined as preparation for living expenses rather than a risky investment. The second concerns income resilience: does your cash flow depend heavily on valuation levels in the crypto industry? If the industry as a whole falls 60%, will job opportunities and bonuses contract as well?
The third is the zero scenario: if this investment went to zero within 90 days, what would happen to your life? More specifically, would you need to delay buying a home, pause tuition payments, or sell other assets? If the answer reaches back to your basic living needs, then “going to zero” is no longer merely volatility you can withstand; it is a loss you would have to accept. The fourth concerns your emotional capacity: if the price falls 20% in a single day, will you still be able to act according to the rules you originally set? True risk tolerance is usually not something you assess for yourself in calm conditions. It is something proven when the market is at its most brutal.
There is one publicly available data point worth considering. Taiwan’s Financial Supervisory Commission has repeatedly warned investors about risks such as crypto’s high volatility and lack of legal protection, and has explicitly stipulated that virtual currency exchanges that have not completed KYC registration may not accept new deposits or withdrawals in Taiwan dollars. The existence of regulations like these is itself a signal: when a market requires a special investor-protection mechanism, it means it has not yet reached the maturity of conventional financial products.
“Risk does not disappear; it only shows up when you are not paying attention.” — This is a principle Warren Buffett has repeatedly emphasized, and it is especially applicable to cryptocurrency.
Building a better framework: Replace “Should I go all in?” with four more specific questions
Rather than debating whether you should go all in, a more useful framework is to first determine whether you can withstand the failure of a single asset. The first step is to define the role of the money: is it idle capital you cannot touch for three years, or an everyday reserve you will need to draw on throughout the next 12 months? The second step is to determine whether this asset makes up such a large proportion of your total assets that it could affect other life plans, such as buying a home, starting a business, or funding your children’s education. The third step is to set exit conditions: at what price level, at what point in time, or in the event of what development will you voluntarily reduce your position?
The fourth step is to prepare a “scenario script.” Assume separately that the price falls 50%, falls 80%, or that the asset fails completely, and work out how your income and expenses would be arranged in each case. The purpose of this exercise is not to predict the future. It is to establish the rules in advance, before your emotions have been depleted. Psychological research has long shown that decision quality declines significantly when people perceive a strong threat. Writing rules down in advance and reviewing them while you are calm is often far more effective than expecting yourself to “be rational” after the fact.
If, after working through these four questions, you still believe that heavy concentration is a reasonable choice, you should at least be able to state clearly what your reasoning is, what your downside limit is, and under what conditions you will admit you were wrong and exit. The core focus of 12W Blog’s discussions of personal finance has never been which asset will rise. It is whether the structure of your decisions leaves you a way out under the worst possible circumstances. Risk awareness matures when you know how much you can afford to lose, not when you dare to go all in.
Key takeaway: Real financial freedom comes from how much failure you can withstand, not how many times you bet right. — 12W Blog